Who was Maggie Gray? Why was she happy?
I scrolled back to the prior message.
It was a message from Mike, my sweetie, to Maggie:
“The sound of your voice yesterday made me happy.”
Which is when I realized that I was in his account, not mine. I began to shiver.
I scrolled back to see the message before that.
It was a message from Mike to Maggie. It said:
“I love you and I have always loved you.”
I’ve re-lived that moment a hundred times. It’s always awful.
What did it feel like? Shock. Horror. Disbelief. I felt like the universe had just gut-punched me.
It was one of the worst moments of my life.
And when I confronted Mike, it was definitely one of the worst moments of his.
“You’re in love with Maggie Gray? Who the hell is Maggie Gray? You’ve never even mentioned her. And now you’re in love with her? How does that work?”
At first, he tried to lie. “She‘s just an old friend from grad school. We re-connected on Facebook a while back. She’s not important.”
But even as adept and practiced a liar as Mike apparently was couldn’t explain away “I love you and I’ve always loved you.”
Eventually he came clean and confessed that he‘d been two-timing me with Maggie Gray for the past 10 years.
And that was the end of a 20-year relationship.
I’m an honest person, and trusting to fault. Over the years, Mike had left his Facebook account open on my computer dozens of times. I’d just log out of his account and into my own. It never occurred to me to spy on him first.
Mike was confident he could maintain a secret relationship because he knew I’d never look for one. He took advantage of my trust. If he hadn’t slipped up that one time and left his account open in such a way that it looked as if I were still in my account, I might never have learned the truth about the man I loved.
I’d still be the trusting chump and Maggie would still be the secret girlfriend.
Which brings us to the other thing people always want to know: “Did Maggie know about you?”
You bet she did! She knew all about me. Although he’d only been cheating on me with her for 10 years, their relationship actually went back 30 years. Mike had cheated on his wife with Maggie three decades ago!
So what have I learned?
Should I have been a little less trusting? Done a little more snooping around? Had I decided to play Nancy Drew, just once, I might have found him out. Then I could have dumped Mr. Infidelity and found a man who actually loved me.
Is that the takeaway — trust, but verify?
After I broke up with Mike, so many friends told me about discovering that their man had cheated that it began to seem as if there wasn’t a guy on the planet who DIDN’T have an secret girlfriend. I heard about flings that lasted a couple of months. Affairs that went on for years. Torrid office romances. Middle-aged men reconnecting with their high school sweethearts on Facebook.
“It’s men,” my friend Laurie said. “None of them can be trusted. They’re ALL like this.”
Is that the lesson? Men can’t be trusted?
One woman, sorting through their husband’s things after his death, found a secret stash of love letters. Another new widow found a photo of her husband’s long-time secretary posed on his office desk top with a big smile on her face, in full bondage gear.
One friend’s father, a rabbi, told his son on his death bed that he’d carried on a secret love affair for decades.
Another friend’s father confessed to his wife as he lay dying from a heart attack that he had a secret family, and pleaded with his wife to financially take care of his mistress’s young children.
Then he recovered.
I really don’t want to believe that all men are like this. I’m heartened by the men I know who are full of contempt for Mike’s behavior, and I agree with the words they use to describe the man who betrayed me. “Heartless and cowardly.” “A man without integrity.” “A weak man and a fool.”
Real men know how to love. Real men don’t need secret girlfriends.
One friend who has been married for 40 years told me, “I would never do anything to hurt my wife. I have no secrets from her. There’s nothing I do or say that I wouldn’t be fine with her knowing. I trust her, and I want her to trust me.”
That’s the kind of man I want the next time around.
Of course, that’s the kind of man I thought my partner was.